Why the decision on Council Tax benefit matters

December 20th 2012

money

Yesterday’s decision in the Senedd to approve new arrangements for helping people with their Council Tax bill marks a potentially significant shift in the Welsh Government thinking. 

The Welsh Government has to date made much of its policies of providing certain kinds of service free to anybody, irrespective of their income. So, free prescriptions, free bus passes for over 60s, free breakfasts for school children and free swimming to name just the most high profile.  The arguments in favour of these “freebies” have been many and various – some, such as free prescriptions – having in my view a rock solid rationale of being part of free NHS treatment, others being rather more shaky.

Yet the idea that people get something “free” has flown out the window when it’s come to Council Tax. The principle of univeralism seems to mean that everyone will now have to pay, not that everyone gets a benefit.  The argument that maintaining the current system is “unaffordable” doesn’t stand up terribly well either – £20 million support for business rates in Enterprise Zones has just been announced and the £20 million for apprenticeships was the settlement reached between Labour and Plaid to get the 2013-14 budget through. 

The decision also muddies the much claimed “clear red water” between the Welsh Government and the UK Government – in supporting a tougher regime of means-testing it is doing more of the same not something radically different.  There was without doubt little time to reinvent a whole new system, not least because the devolution of Council Tax support came as something of a surprise and very late in the day. But it wasn’t and isn’t impossible.

It remains to be seen if the regulations approved yesterday are short-term expediency to be replaced by something more in keeping with the Welsh Government’s ideology, or whether they really do mark the begining of a shift in position that could, in time see the end of other universal so-called “freebies”.  

0

Leave a Reply

In Print

Subscribers' Magazine

Exchange – Issue 7

‘Resilient communities’ is a phrase that’s been hard to avoid in recent months and is central to the discussions about the future of Communities First.  Great though it sounds, it is much less clear what resilience means or how it Read more »

Exchange – Issue 6

It’s been almost five months since the UK voted to leave the EU. As the initial shock of the referendum result dies down, the latest edition of Exchange looks at the impact that Brexit could have on Wales. Our contributors Read more »

More from the Subscribers' Magazine »

Other Publications

More from Other Publications »

Newsletter

Keep up to Date

Sign up to our monthly e-news to keep up to date with our ideas, events and resources.

Support Us

Subscribe Today!

Help Wales to be fair, prosperous and sustainable - and get some great benefits too!

Join / Donate »

Events

June 14th 2017

What next after the election?

Whatever the result of the election on June 8th, big changes are ahead over the next five years.  Come and join us for a great lunch-time discussion! We are pleased to invite you to discuss the results of the general Read more »

July 5th 2017

Making City Deals Inclusive

Making City Deals Inclusive Wednesday 5th July 2017 Media Briefing Room, Senedd, Cardiff, CF99 1NA Kindly sponsored by Jeremy Miles AM With City Deals now approved for Cardiff and Swansea – and similar deals on the agenda for the rest of Read more »