Wales' most innovative and influential think tank

Connect: Twitter Facebook LinkedInTel: 01685 350938

Why Wales should be prepping for benefit devolution

November 22nd 2016

As we launch our latest report, ‘The Future of Attendance Allowance’, the Bevan Foundation’s Policy and Research Officer, Nisreen Mansour, explains why we need to start preparing now for the prospect of social security devolution.


Almost a year ago, the UK Government published a consultation document on the future of local government funding in England. While this may not sound too relevant, the devil was in the detail – it included the announcement that they were also considering the devolution of Attendance Allowance to Wales, as well as local authorities in England.

Attendance Allowance is claimed by people aged 65 and over with a disability who require additional care. Just over 100,000 people receive it in Wales, at a cost of approximately £400 million a year.Wales has the highest claimant rate amongst over 65s – around 17%.

The proposal to devolve responsibility for this benefit did not go unnoticed. Campaigners immediately suspected that it was a way of  covertly abolishing Attendance Allowance, with the budget being absorbed into the social care pot. The Local Government Association in England objected on the grounds that local authorities do not want to  be responsible for administering a demand-led benefit without adequate funding and the Welsh Government said it was “extremely cautious” about how it would be funded.

However opposition does not mean that it will not happen. And importantly for Wales, if responsibility for Attendance Allowance is to be devolved to local authorities in England, it is hard to imagine the DWP remaining responsible for administering a benefit solely to Welsh claimants. Therefore, even if we don’t like the prospect of it we should be doing everything we can to prepare for the devolution of Attendance Allowance in future.

So how should we prepare?

Scotland offers an example of what we can expect. When responsibility for various disability social security benefits was devolved, funding for this was determined as an addition to the block grant. A separate agreement was published, which stated that funding would be based on “the UK Government’s spending on these areas in Scotland in the year immediately prior to the devolution of powers,” and then ‘Barnettised’ for future years. The key point is that the initial baseline addition to the block grant was based on what was spent on the benefits in the previous year – the claimant rate.

Wales should take note. Attendance Allowance is suspected of being under-claimed, with people not receiving it who should be, and people receiving the lower rate who are eligible for the higher rate. If the problem with under-claiming is not resolved before the benefit is devolved, the Welsh Government could be subject to a funding agreement which is based on a worryingly inaccurate picture of all those who are eligible for the benefit.

This is why we’ve recommended that the Welsh Government should be preparing for benefit devolution now. If Attendance Allowance is devolved, the claimant rate needs to give as true a reflection as possible of those who are eligible for it in Wales. A take-up campaign to encourage people to find out if they’re entitled to it is an essential step to achieving this.

The message from our research is simple – if we’re not making sure that everyone who is eligible for Attendance Allowance is claiming it, then we may lose out in a future funding settlement.

Nisreen Mansour is the Policy and Research Officer at the Bevan Foundation.

To find out more about the Bevan Foundation’s research on the future of Attendance Allowance in Wales and to download the report, click here.


Leave a Reply

In Print

Supporter Magazine

Exchange Issue 10, Spring 2018

“Refreshing, timely and balanced – Exchange has its finger on the pulse” The latest edition of our exclusive supporters’ magazine brings together a range of contributors to explore some of the most current and important issues in Welsh public life. Read more »

Exchange – Issue 9

Well-being in Wales The latest edition of our exclusive supporters’ magazine looks at well-being in Wales from a range of different perspectives. Our excellent range of contributors looks at health and social care in Wales while considering different aspects of Read more »

More from the Supporter Magazine »

Other Publications

Poverty in Wales 2018

The Joseph Rowntree Foundation’s latest report provides an up-to-date analysis on the current status of poverty in Wales The report looks back over the last twenty years, examining the poverty trends in Wales, comparing Wales with the rest of the Read more »

More from Other Publications »


Stay informed

Keep up to date and gain new insights and inspiration with Spark, our FREE e-news

Sign Up For Insights »

Support Us

Support lasting solutions today!

We need YOUR help to create equality, justice and prosperity for everyone in Wales

Support Us »


May 11th 2018

Understanding Poverty

UNDERSTANDING POVERTY:  What it means for your organisation and what you can do about it 11th May 2018, 1.30 – 4.30 Erddig Room, Glyndwr University, Wrexham Essential training for everyone working with people on low incomes WE REGRET THAT THIS EVENT Read more »