Connect: Twitter Facebook LinkedInTel: 01685 350938

Careers Advice: time for an independent review

January 23rd 2017

The Welsh Government’s recent announcement on the provision of careers advice makes the case for an Independent Commission on guidance and support all the more pressing, says Victoria Winckler

Image of 3 people asking about careers

Photo: Careers Wales

In the Assembly’s Christmas recess, Welsh Ministers announced a ‘revised approach’ to the ‘control, management and funding of Careers Wales’.  This announcement doesn’t give much away, but signals that there are shifts in Careers Wales’s management of resources and funding.

Organisationally, the careers service has been in a state of semi-permanent revolution.

In the mid 1990s, careers advice was effectively privatised by being removed from local authority control and placed in seven companies that roughly corresponded with the then county councils.  Devolution brought the formation of Careers Wales in 2001, with the seven companies operating within the Careers Wales remit and brand. Fast forward to 2013 and the seven careers companies were wound up and Careers Wales became ‘Careers Choices Dewis Gyrfa, a company limited by guarantee which is wholly-owned by the Welsh Government.

A few years into the operation of Careers Choices Dewis Gyrfa and Ministers are looking at “set of strategic options for the future direction of the company”. One of the options that has found favour appears to be competitive tender, with the provision of advice to the new Employability and Apprenticeship Programme up for grabs.

Add to this, Careers Wales has seen its funding cut dramatically. According to UNISON, Careers Wales’ core funding from Welsh Government has fallen from £42 million to £18 million in five years.

Does it matter?  In a word, yes.

The review of evidence of ‘what works’ commissioned by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation found that provision of good quality, expert advice and support to people of all ages (not just school-leavers) could make a big difference to whether someone moved out of poverty.For this reason, the report on solving poverty in Wales included a specific recommendation that the provision of careers advice should be significantly enhanced.

And boy is this needed!

Dig a bit deeper into the world of careers and you’ll find gaps and duplication of provision.

In schools, it is schools themselves who are responsible for the provision of careers education (Careers Wales does the ‘guidance’). It is at school that young people make critical – and often career limiting – decisions.  Careers Wales has an ‘offer’ for schools with 136 of Wales’ 205 secondaries achieving the Careers Wales Quality Mark, according to its annual report.  But for many children, it’s still down to Mr Jones the PE teacher to tell you you how to become an astrophysicist or lawyer or whatever.

Young people can also access Careers Wales’ services, although the Welsh Government’s remit letter to Careers Wales makes clear that the priorities are those with the most challenging circumstances e.g. young people in the justice system, with statements of special educational need or unemployed 16-17 year olds.

Employment ‘schemes’ such as Work Programme or Bridges to Work often have access to guidance and support as part of the programme, not least as it is in the providers’ interest to get participants into a job (probably any job).

And the rest of the population of Wales? Well, you can try Careers Wales adult skills gateway should, as an adult, you think of looking on the Careers Wales website and know what an ‘skills gateway’ is. But chances are you don’t, and so you’ll rely on family, friends and colleagues if you need help with a change of direction.

Why an Independent Commission?

With the careers service’s turbulent history and the considerable gaps in provision, the JRF report called for an independent commission on the provision of advice and guidance.

It’s not clear exactly what the Welsh Government’s decision involves still less what the implications are, but with a risk of further turbulence and fragmentation of provision, the case for an independent commission to ensure that young people and adults get good quality information and advice is compelling.

So far with the announcement made in the Assembly recess, no news coverage of it that I can find, and no questions about it in the Senedd, the lack of investment, gaps and fragmentation that passes for careers guidance looks set to continue.

Victoria Winckler is Director of the Bevan Foundation

24th Jan 2017: minor amendments and corrections made to reflect comments from Careers Wales

Leave a Reply

In Print

Subscribers' Magazine

Exchange – Issue 8

Looking to the Local The latest edition of our exclusive subscribers’ magazine considers the role of ‘the local’ in Welsh public policy. An eclectic mix of contributors look at how place-based initiatives have worked in Wales, as well as what should be Read more »

Exchange – Issue 7

‘Resilient communities’ is a phrase that’s been hard to avoid in recent months and is central to the discussions about the future of Communities First.  Great though it sounds, it is much less clear what resilience means or how it Read more »

More from the Subscribers' Magazine »

Other Publications

Taking the Valleys Forward

Taking the Valleys Forward: how the Valleys Taskforce can build prosperity and security This short paper brings together some of the Bevan Foundation’s recent work on the economy and labour market into a set of proposals for that would help Read more »

More from Other Publications »


Keep up to Date

Sign up to our monthly e-news to keep up to date with our ideas, events and resources.

Support Us

Subscribe Today!

Help Wales to be fair, prosperous and sustainable - and get some great benefits too!

Join / Donate »


Join us or sign up to our free newsletter to find out about upcoming events.