Connect: Twitter Facebook LinkedInTel: 01685 350938

The rules of the political game in 2011.

| January 5th 2011

Over the next couple of weeks, we are going to run several articles by respected commentators concerning their predictions and aspirations for 2011 regarding the particular field they work in. As the Yes Campaign for Wales to have law making powers in devolved areas launched last night, it seems appropriate to write about my own predictions and hopes concerning constitutional change.

Constitutional issues have always been seen as an issue solely for political geeks, and have thus historically been marginalised as a minor concern. However with several major constitutional changes introduced by the previous government, and more to be introduced by the coalition, the British constitution has undergone and is undergoing a big transformation. In a way the constitution is playing catch up to changes in the political culture. There has also been a major shift from a two party system towards a multi-party system where at least 6 political parties are capable of winning seats in the various parliaments and assemblies, and the expenses scandals and growth of online forms of political commentary have –for better or for worse – ended the traditional deference shown towards MPs and elected representatives.

Constitutional issues are also important because they decide the rules of the political game. Often those rules favour the interests of those who designed them, and those who have been involved in political campaigning from the perspective of social justice have sometimes felt that the system is against them. It has been described as like a rugby or football team having to constantly play away and uphill, occasionally you may score a goal or even win a match, but the odds are against you.

So the changes that have occurred over the last 10 years have been broadly welcomed, and some of the changes planned to occur are increasingly initiated on all sides of the political spectrum. However on some major or controversial constitutional issues referenda are still required.  Hence this year will see referenda on moving to AV as well as the welsh referendum.

In 2011, regardless of the result of either of the referenda, constitutional changes will occur. Many will be minor changes broadly welcomed across the spectrum, such as publishing more details of government and local authority spending online, others will be major changes pushed through more controversially such as reducing the number of MPs in Westminster with re-drawn boundaries. My prediction  is this that Wales will vote Yes to greater responsibility, but unfortunately the lack of enthusiasm for AV even amongst supporters of electoral reform will see the No campaign victorious.

But predictions are not the same as hopes, and my hopes are that both referenda are won by the yes campaigns, who run positive messages throughout. Furthermore the process of de-centralisation continues with devolved institutions created in England, media pluralism becomes wider with Murdoch’s bid to control Sky blocked, and libel laws are reformed more liberally. Basically that the political game takes place on a more level playing field, has a greater number of participants and becomes more enjoyable for those who play it.

Leave a Reply

× one = 9

In Print

Members' Magazine


Exchange March 2015

Our new magazine for members puts all those working for social justice in Wales in touch with each other. With a fresh new look, new features and columnists and a focus on ideas and best practice, Exchange  offers:  opportunities to Read more »

Review 26 Cover 300 x 400

Review 26

Review no. 26 features some challenging articles on public service reform, local democracy and engaging with people – public bodies in Wales sadly have a long way to go. We also take a look at the relationship between work and health, reveal the perverse impact Read more »

More from the Members' Magazine »

Other Publications


Women’s Equality Now: Devolution

Wales has long celebrated its achievements in bringing gender equality into public and political life.  But there are questions about how deep those changes went, and whether they will be sustained in coming years. This briefing highlights what devolution did for women’s representation Read more »

More from Other Publications »


Keep up to Date

Don’t miss our ideas and opportunities – sign up to our monthly e-newsletter.

Support Us

Make a Difference

Help Wales to be fair, prosperous and sustainable - and get some great benefits too!

Join / Donate »


Join us or sign up to our free newsletter to find out about upcoming events.