Connect: Twitter Facebook LinkedInTel: 01685 350938

Bigging up the Big Society?

| April 7th 2011

On 27 March, The Observer published a story on the news that the Arts and Humanities Research Council (AHRC) has included the Big Society (BS) in its research agenda:.  Last Sunday I and 187 other academics signed a letter in protest  . (Note: the list of signatories is cut short in the published version.) Here I give some background for my own motivations in putting the letter together.

Since David Cameron first mentioned it the term ‘Big Society’ has gone from a slippery, ideologically loaded election slogan to a slippery, ideologically loaded part of the landscape.  It has become a thing.  People refer to it in meetings, workshops, and discussion forums as if it’s a kind of given – something we must engage with, because it’s there.  And it’s there – with its attendant websites, tsars, and the whiff of the promise of funding – pretty much entirely because the government has put it there.

There is a lot that might be said about the coherence of the notion, its ideological ballast and its ultimate purposes.  But that, in our letter, wasn’t the point.  Our argument was that governments should not use the academic research councils – there are seven, of which the AHRC is the smallest – as instruments through which to pursue their own political agendas.  It wouldn’t matter if the thesis in question were the ‘Third Way’, or ‘we’ve never had it so good’, or ‘alarm clock Britain’.  Academic research is not there to endorse, pursue, bolster or otherwise lend credibility to party political slogans.  Rather, its job is critical enquiry.

Unsurprisingly, this is territory academics are loath to give up.  When the AHRC announced its Delivery Plan for 2011-15 , there was predictable anger among the researchers on whom the ARHC depends to achieve its goals.  The plan makes it clear that the AHRC is committed to contributing to the BS project.  It suggests that AHRC-funded research might ‘clarify and contextualise’ the concepts used in its promotion, and to do this in collaboration with government departments themselves committed to the promotion of the whole BS agenda.

Things have been moving this way for a while.  Since New Labour, there has been concern for the safety of the Haldane principle – see the commentary by Andrew Chitty at  The principle, simply, is that decisions on where academic research funding goes should be taken by academics, and not the state.  The current Government has now restated this, to mean that while government cannot interfere in specific funding decisions, it can direct the councils to concentrate a proportion of their funding in line with ‘key national strategic priorities’.  It is also appropriate, says a December 2010 document from the Department for Business Innovation and Skills ‘for Ministers to ask Research Councils to consider how best they can contribute to these priorities’.  Hence the graceless spectacle of research councils such as the AHRC at pains to show how their own particular programmes might contribute to the BS agenda.

Leave a Reply

+ four = 13

In Print

Members' Magazine


Exchange March 2015

Our new magazine for members puts all those working for social justice in Wales in touch with each other. With a fresh new look, new features and columnists and a focus on ideas and best practice, Exchange  offers:  opportunities to Read more »

Review 26 Cover 300 x 400

Review 26

Review no. 26 features some challenging articles on public service reform, local democracy and engaging with people – public bodies in Wales sadly have a long way to go. We also take a look at the relationship between work and health, reveal the perverse impact Read more »

More from the Members' Magazine »

Other Publications


Women’s Equality Now: Devolution

Wales has long celebrated its achievements in bringing gender equality into public and political life.  But there are questions about how deep those changes went, and whether they will be sustained in coming years. This briefing highlights what devolution did for women’s representation Read more »

More from Other Publications »


Keep up to Date

Don’t miss our ideas and opportunities – sign up to our monthly e-newsletter.

Support Us

Make a Difference

Help Wales to be fair, prosperous and sustainable - and get some great benefits too!

Join / Donate »


July 7th 2015

The 2015 Bevan Prize for Health and Wellbeing

The 2015 Bevan Prize for Health and Wellbeing will be announced and awarded at an event in the House of Commons on Tuesday 7th July 2015, where nominees will be joined by guests to celebrate their work in the field of health and wellbeing and commitment to NHS values.